Okay so I just spent the last three weeks testing literally every all-in-one planner I could get my hands on because like five different clients asked me the same question and I figured I should actually have a proper answer instead of just going “uh depends on your style?”
The Digital Ones Everyone Keeps Asking About
Let me start with Notion because obviously that’s where everyone’s brain goes first. I’ve been using it for my own planning for about two years now and here’s the thing nobody tells you: the setup is absolutely brutal. Like I’m talking 4-5 hours minimum if you’re building from scratch. BUT there are templates now that actually don’t suck. I bought the “Ultimate Life Planner” template from some creator on Etsy for like $12 and honestly it saved me so much time.
The daily/monthly combo view in Notion works really well once you get it configured. You can toggle between your daily tasks and see them automatically populate in your monthly overview. The databases talk to each other which sounds complicated but basically means you write something once and it shows up everywhere it needs to. My dog knocked over my coffee right in the middle of setting up a client’s Notion workspace last week and I lost like 30 minutes of work because I forgot to let it sync, so just… make sure you’re online when you’re building stuff.
What Actually Works in Notion
- The calendar view for monthly planning is genuinely good
- You can embed literally anything – I have my workout tracker and budget spreadsheet right in my planner
- The mobile app got way better in the last update
- Templates can be reused infinitely so you set it up once
What’s Annoying
- It’s slow sometimes, especially if you have a ton of pages
- The learning curve is real
- You need internet for most features to work properly
- Can feel like overkill if you just want a simple planner
Wait I forgot to mention ClickUp which is actually my secret favorite for the all-in-one thing. It’s marketed as project management software but I’ve been using it as a personal planner and it’s honestly better than Notion for this specific use case. The hierarchy is: everything view, then monthly view, then daily tasks. You can set recurring tasks which show up automatically in your daily list, and the calendar view actually shows your tasks BY TIME which Notion doesn’t really do well.
The Paper Options That Don’t Make Me Want To Scream
Okay so if you’re a paper person like apparently 60% of my clients still are, I’ve tested a ridiculous number of these. Currently sitting at my desk with like 8 different planners open which probably looks insane.
The Passion Planner is the one I recommend most often and I know it’s kinda basic but there’s a reason everyone uses it. The weekly spreads have space for daily tasks AND a monthly overview on the same two-page spread. Well, not exactly the same spread, it’s at the beginning of each month but you get what I mean. The paper quality is genuinely good, my pens don’t bleed through even when I’m using my Tombow markers.
Passion Planner Specifics
The daily sections are broken into half-hour increments from 6am to 8pm which works for most people. There’s a separate section for “good things that happened” that some people love and some people find annoying, you can just ignore it. The monthly roadmap pages are actually useful, not just decorative. I use them to block out big projects and deadlines.
Size options are compact, classic, and large. I’m gonna be honest, the compact is too small unless you have tiny handwriting or just don’t write much. The classic is the sweet spot. It’s about 8.5 x 11 inches, fits in most bags, enough space to actually write stuff.
The Panda Planner Situation
This one’s more structured which some people really need. It has morning review sections, daily priorities, evening review. Very productivity-focused. The monthly section is at the beginning of each month with a full calendar grid plus space for monthly goals and priorities.
I tested this for three weeks straight and here’s what I found: if you actually USE all the sections, it’s incredibly effective. Like annoyingly effective. I got so much done. But if you’re someone who skips the reflection parts, you’re paying for features you won’t use and there’s less space for actual tasks.
The paper is thick, like really thick. Almost too thick? The planner is chunky because of it. But zero bleed-through even with fountain pens which I tested because one of my clients is very extra about her pens.
The Weird Middle Ground Options
Oh and another thing – reMarkable 2 tablet. Okay this is gonna sound weird but hear me out. It’s a digital tablet that writes like paper, and you can use it as an all-in-one planner. I got one to test after a client swore by it and I was super skeptical.
The feel is actually really close to paper. You can download planner templates or create your own. The monthly and daily pages can be organized however you want. You can search your handwritten notes which is honestly magic. And everything syncs to the cloud automatically.
The Catch With reMarkable
It’s expensive. Like $400+ expensive. And there’s a subscription if you want all the cloud features which feels ridiculous for a digital notebook. The screen is black and white only, no color. It’s not backlit so you need light to see it. And it only does notes/planning, you can’t browse the internet or check email which is actually kind of the point but might annoy you.
I’ve been using mine for two months now and the battery lasts forever, like 2 weeks of daily use. That part is legitimately impressive.
The Hybrid Approach That Actually Works
Okay so funny story, I was watching The Bear while testing planners (great show btw, very stressful) and I realized most people don’t need to choose just one system. The hybrid approach is using a digital monthly overview and a paper daily planner.
Google Calendar or Outlook for the monthly bird’s eye view. You can see everything at once, share it with family/coworkers, set reminders. Then use a simple daily planner like a Leuchtturm1917 or Hobonichi for your actual daily tasks and notes.
Why This Combo Works
- Digital monthly calendar is accessible everywhere, on your phone when you’re out
- Paper daily pages let you actually think through your day
- Less pressure to make the “perfect” system since each part does one thing well
- Cheaper than buying an expensive all-in-one that tries to do everything
The Hobonichi Techo is my current daily carry for this setup. It’s a Japanese planner, one page per day, dated. The pages are thin but don’t bleed, it’s small enough to carry everywhere, and there’s a monthly calendar at the front of each month for quick reference. I just keep my detailed monthly planning in Google Calendar and use the Hobonichi monthly pages for overview/backup.
What to Actually Consider Before Buying
This is gonna sound obvious but I see people mess this up constantly. Think about when and where you’ll actually use your planner.
If you’re at a desk all day, a large planner or digital system makes sense. If you’re running around, you need something portable. I have a client who bought a beautiful large Erin Condren planner and it sat on her desk at home because she couldn’t carry it to work. Total waste.
The Questions I Make Clients Answer
- Do you already use your phone for everything or do you actively avoid screens?
- Are you planning work tasks, personal life, or both?
- Do you need time blocking or just task lists?
- Will you actually use reflection/gratitude sections or just feel guilty about skipping them?
- What’s your actual budget including any accessories you’ll need?
The Budget Options That Don’t Suck
Not everyone wants to drop $40+ on a planner and that’s totally valid. The Blue Sky planners from Target are like $15-20 and they’re honestly pretty decent. The monthly spreads are clear, the weekly pages have enough space for most people, and the paper handles normal pens fine.
I tested the Blue Sky “Analeis” weekly/monthly planner and it held up for three months of daily use. The binding started coming loose after that but for $15, whatever. The monthly calendar pages are at the front which some people don’t like, they prefer monthly tabs throughout, but I got used to it.
Moleskine also has weekly/monthly planners that go on sale pretty regularly. The paper is hit or miss depending on which specific line you get, but the layout is clean and functional.
For People Who Overcomplicate Everything
If you’re like me and you’ve tried 47 different systems and nothing sticks, maybe the problem isn’t the planner. I spent six months jumping between Notion, Todoist, Trello, paper planners, bullet journals… my client canceled so I spent an hour comparing the Silk + Sonder planner to the Erin Condren LifePlanner and realized I was just procrastinating.
Sometimes you just need to pick something and use it for at least a month before deciding it doesn’t work. The all-in-one planner that’s actually best is the one you’ll consistently use, which is annoyingly vague advice but it’s true.
My Current Setup (As of This Week)
I’m using ClickUp for monthly planning and project tracking, a Hobonichi Techo for daily tasks and notes, and Google Calendar for appointments because I need that to sync with everyone else. Is it perfect? No. Does it work? Yeah, actually it does.
The monthly view in ClickUp shows me everything due this month. Each morning I look at that and write my top priorities in my Hobonichi. Appointments go straight into Google Calendar when they’re made. The systems talk to each other because I make them, not because they’re automatically integrated.
The Ones I Don’t Recommend
Full Focus Planner is too expensive for what you get and the daily pages are weirdly structured. Happy Planner is fine if you’re into decorating but the disc binding system is annoying for actual planning. Commit30 planner has too many sections, feels like homework.
Rocketbook seemed cool in theory, it’s reusable and scans to the cloud, but the writing experience isn’t great and you have to use specific pens. I tested it for two weeks and kept forgetting to microwave the pages to erase them which defeats the whole purpose.
Digital Ones That Disappointed Me
Evernote is clunky for planning even though people try to make it work. Asana is too project-management focused, feels weird for personal planning. Microsoft OneNote is… fine? But nothing special for this specific use case. GoodNotes on iPad is actually pretty good but then you’re locked into Apple ecosystem.
The Real Answer Nobody Wants to Hear
The best all-in-one planner is probably going to be a combination of 2-3 tools that each do one thing really well rather than one tool that does everything mediocrely. Unless you’re willing to spend serious time setting up something like Notion, or you’re okay with the limitations of paper planners.
For most people I recommend: simple digital monthly calendar (Google Calendar, free) + paper daily planner (Passion Planner or Hobonichi, $25-40) + a notes app for random thoughts (Apple Notes, Google Keep, whatever, free). Total cost under $50, covers all your bases, doesn’t require a engineering degree to set up.
If you absolutely need everything in one place, ClickUp for digital or Passion Planner for paper are my top picks. They’re not perfect but they’re the most consistently good options I’ve tested. The Passion Planner specifically gets recommended by me like 70% of the time because it just works for most people and doesn’t try to be too clever about it.



